I know last week I handled something pretty simple. No one is going to disagree with the fact that books are good. If you disagree with that you sound uneducated and nobody wants that. Now, we are going to handle something a little trickier that some of you may disagree with me on. If you do, please comment. I would love to hear your thoughts and then I will let you fight it out with each other in the comment thread much like the Roman elite did with the gladiators, or like the fighting pit in Game of Thrones (SPOILER ALERT!).
Very simply, all I want to say about film is that I consider it to be a high form of art. What this means is that it is more than mere popcorn fodder or a means by which you can get someone you are interested in alone and in the dark (come on, we all know we’ve tried that! That’s what horror films are for.)
I know the arguments are diverse and many against film being a high form of art like painting or novels, sculpture, etc. They’re passive, merely for entertainment, do not call us to dwell on anything higher than boobs, sex (yes, it is so prevalent I am counting those two things separately. And if you’re not in middle school you know that one does not necessitate the other.)
explosions and action. Please note that I am discussing film as art NOT THE FILM INDUSTRY! That is an entirely different topic we will tackle later. When discussing novels or paintings as art, we don’t talk about how it gets done, just that it got done. So let us do that here.
First, in defense of film. Like any art form there are good and bad examples. There are bad paintings and good paintings, good novels and bad novels. Same goes for film. If you only watch Hollywood Summer Blockbusters, of course you would think that films are passive and only fodder for explosions, CGI’ed dinosaurs and robots (not that there’s anything wrong with that). But if you only read mainstream, pop-culture books, you would probably believe the same about novels. Let me illustrate with an example. If I had never read a book and started reading based upon what was the most highly advertised in books stores and discussed in pop-culture I would end up reading: 50 Shades of Grey, Twilight, The Hunger Games and things of that nature. I am not saying these are bad books (or maybe I am. They’re not the best written things ever) but what I am saying is there is not much to them. They’re fairly simple and at the end of the day are not really worth a re-read or hours of textual analysis in a classroom. Films work the same way!
If you only watch watered-down, mainstream pop-culture films that are highly advertised then of course there won’t be much there! That’s what they’re designed to do! They’re designed to be shallow, easily accessible and non-confrontational. It gets as many people as possible to see it! The end goal: MONEY! Now I am not saying that making money is a bad goal, just that MONEY IS THE ROOT OF ALL EVIL. Moving on....
What I want to argue for is how people choose and engage their films. Just like with books, you are provided a wide array of choices. Some intelligent and some not as much. There is a place for both of them. (How pretentious do I sound right now? Comment below on a scale of 1-10!) Watch all the Marvel movies in a row! (I have a list of the ones you can skip) Have fun, invite your friends over, talk about why Robert Downey Jr. is the greatest actor ever and why Robert Pattinson is “so totally hot!” (not my words). But then make time for something a little more engaging, something that commands your attention. You have Netflix! Indie films are so easy to get your hands on! Watch Snowpiercer, Pi, Boyhood, Chinatown, Sunset Boulevard, Psycho, Drive, The Raid. This list is certainly not all inclusive but they are all worth watching. Now, this brings me to my next point: ENGAGE!
It’s pretty easy to engage books. If you’re not engaged, you’re not reading, plain and simple. If you’re watching a film, you have to be intentional! Put down your phone, tell your friend to “Shut it!” (you can tell them I told you to do it) and keep your eyes on the screen. Do what you do with books or with paintings (it’s almost like film is a mix of the two of them!) Analyze the character arcs, listen to how they talk to each other and also analyze the imagery. If a film is done well, everything is done intentionally. From costuming, to props, to set pieces, everything serves a purpose. For example, in Chinatown, everything is a circle. What’s the theme of Chinatown? Everything is circular. It all comes back around. “Wow, that’s clever,” you may say. And I may say, “Yeah! It is! Also, Jack Nicholson is a great actor, isn’t he?”
There is so much to look at and explore in a film, I can’t imagine not being engaged with it (unless it’s bad or my girlfriend gets jealous). The point is, if you find the right film it’s difficult to not see them as solely entertaining popcorn fodder. Explore and enjoy!
And, before I forget, let’s not forget those who claim “movies aren’t as good as books.” Let’s explore the prime argument they use, shall we? When a film adaptation of a book is released everyone says “It wasn’t as good as the book!” To that I say “Unless you’re talking about The Hunger Games (in which case the movies are SO MUCH BETTER) then, duh!”
Of course a film adaptation will fall short of a book. THEY ARE TWO DIFFERENT MEDIUMS! You can’t compare the two! The way you tell stories with them is vastly different. The question you ask people who say this is, “have you ever read a book adaptation of a film?” The answer is hopefully “NO!” because they are horrible! It just doesn’t work!
Now I am not saying that all adaptations are bad. Jurassic Park, for example, is an amazing film that has stood the test of time and is a milestone in cinema and a classic! Do I think it is better than the book? No. BUT, do I think the book is better than the movie? No! How can this be possible? BECAUSE I THINK THEY’RE BOTH EQUAL! If you love the book and then watch the film version and judge the movie by the same standards as the book, of course you’ll think the book is better! I am arguing that while you engage with the film, you judge it on a different set of standards. Not lesser standards, but different. Let me give you some examples of things films have in them that books do not: Actors/Actresses, Cinematography (camera angles/movement, lighting, etc.), Technology (CGI, Effects, etc.), Costuming, and more. (If you are confused by what to judge films on then look at the Oscar categories.)
All I want to say is films and books are on the same level. They’re apples and oranges to each other and one should not be considered better than the other. Do I think you can analyze a film and have an educated discussion about in highschool? Yes! I’ve done it. The great thing about film is that it is accessible. As we discussed with novels earlier, there is a barrier if people can’t read. With film, you have to have eyes and you have to be able to understand words coming out of people’s mouths. I’m pretty sure every human does that on a daily basis (some better than others). The point is, think about the implications visuals mediums, like film, have on a global scale where everyone isn’t necessarily read books from the time they’re born.
Books have an edge because they force interaction, but film has an edge because of accessibility. Speaking of which: check out a foreign film some time and see how other cultures tell stories. Subtitles are great! And then you can read too! Two birds, one film! (That should be the name of a YouTube video!)
I hope this was educational. Please tear each other apart in the comment section for my amusement and if you like, tell me how pretentious I sounded. I’ll make it easier by telling you that I was “one of those film students” in college.